Social proof recency decay is the phenomenon where social proof elements (review count, recent purchases, real-time activity) lose persuasive impact as their age increases, since users perceive old social proof as less relevant to their current decision.
Displaying old static numbers, such as a total customer count unchanged for months, can have the opposite of the intended effect, signaling stagnation instead of active, ongoing credibility.
Why it matters
Keeping social proof updated and visibly recent is more effective for conversion than displaying impressive but obviously static figures, making periodic updates a necessity, not an option.